I tried #gnu #guix SD for the first night and restored my #debian backup on the same night. It's and has several fascinating ideas but has only few problems which are severe and deal breakers for me.

The idea of having a functional build/package manager system is amazing and an operating system around it is every cooler. Creating your entire OS based on a lisp DSL is the dream. I'm a huge lisp fan and I started using #gnu #guix with love of #gnu, #lisp and #linux on my heart but to be honest it wasn't what i expected.

Show thread

The biggest problem for me was the lack of binary compatibility and the fact that they don't want to be compatible was a instance no for me. You can't use official binaries for #firefox and many other free tools..... #gnu #guix

Another one is the fact that they enforce you to follow the #fsf definition of freedom which is like you CAN'T use those softwares that are not free in our opinion that is against the freedom of will and I don't want that. It's sad to see that this mindset is getting more popular and more extreme among gnu project. That's why I like #debian. You're free to do what you want and nothing is holding you back. These reason made me realize the #gnu #guix SD with all the shiny ideas isn't for me.


@lxsameer Guix has committed to the Free Software Distribution Guidelines, which includes distributing only free software and not steering users towards non-free software. But Guix does not prevent a person from running whatever software they want on their system, and methods for doing so are documented in the manual.

Sign in to participate in the conversation

The social network of the future: No ads, no corporate surveillance, ethical design, and decentralization! Own your data with Mastodon!